Exam Question:
To what extent can the films you have studied for this topic be accused of reinforcing rather than challenging the stereotypes? (35 Marks).
Films tend to follow and reinforce stereotypes as a way of making the characters easier for the audience to understand or relate to. This however means that films reinforce negative stereotypes that out shine the positive representations seen in films. In the films I have studied they go a long way to both enforce stereotypes and challenge them by giving the characters common traits associated with the group that they fit in but show a more positive side to how the characters eventually overcome or don't follow them.
An example of a stereotype seen in a film I have looked at is that young boys from estates are violent and disorderly. The film in which this stereotype is enforced is La Haine (1995) directed by Mathieu Kassovitz. In this film the audience are introduced to three characters, Hubert, Vince and Saïd, who all live in a rough estate within France. The three protagonists are shown to be traveling around Paris causing havoc by having constant interactions with the police and even trying to steal a car. This shows to the audience that young boys living on estates are violent criminals. This film goes a long way to reinforce the negative stereotypes of young boys on estates as based on the issues that the film depicts, Paris Riots, the audience are shown the aggressive nature of the rioters through the three protagonists. The protagonists, although from different ethnic backgrounds, share a common stereotype as a group because other characters believe that because of where they are from and how they sometimes behave they are seen to be like the rioters at the beginning of the film. Although the characters don't always conform to the negative stereotypes forced upon them they cant escape how people perceive them.
However it could be argued that when the audience looks at the characters individually the film does challenge common stereotypes, especially looking at the protagonist Hubert. Hubert comes from an African background and the common stereotype associated with black people are that they are violent. Hubert however contradicts this as he tries to do everything to change what people expect form him. He runs his own gym where he helps people similar to him have somewhere to train and stay out of trouble. Rather than following what people think of him, he has tried to stray away from the common stereotype. This is significant as although as a group the three characters are negatively stereotyped, individually they all challenge (particularly Hubert) stereotypes associated with the the group that they are put into.
Another common stereotype that is often shown within films is that disabled people are dependant on other people and that they can't do things a 'normal' person can. Disability in film often follow negative stereotypes which aren't often challenged. However a film that challenges the stereotypes linked with disability is Rust and Bone (2012) directed by Jacques Audiard. The film challenges disability stereotypes by linking disability with femininity. Where this is evident in the film is the relationship between Stephanie and Alain. Stephanie is a double amputee following an incident at her work. One of the main issues that is depicted in this film is her trying to 'find' her femininity again and gaining her confidence back whilst dealing with her new disability. Whilst she sees herself as different and strange, Alain as a 'normal' women and is the same person he met before the incident. Their relationship is the main way the film challenges stereotypes. However, in the beginning of the film it could be argued that because of her behaviour and her reluctance towards her disability shows her conforming to the stereotypes that disabled people aren't the same as abled people. Because of the developing bond between Stephanie and Alain, it portrays the idea that it is a very normal relationship which the audience may not have expected due to Stephanie's disability. The relationship is just like any other relationship within other films and their for go against rather than enforce the negative stereotypes. Rust and Bone goes along way to challenge stereotypes linked with disability as it has made it clear that disability doesn't mean the person is any less capable than anyone else. The relationship is made to be like any other relationship.
In conclusion, In the films I have studied, they have all challenged stereotypes more than they enforce them. Although La Haine does mostly reinforce stereotypes, it also however makes a point to go against certain stereotypes in order to change the expectations of the audience. La Haine and Rust and Bone go along way to challenge stereotypes by showing the original negative perception of an issue and then turning it into something positive.